Alright, it’s been a while since I’ve actually posted anything – but here goes… obsession of the season: Ice Cream. Ever since Love and Curtis gave me an ice cream maker attachment for the Kitchen Aid mixer for my birthday, I have been utterly OBSESSED with making ice cream. I remember the first time I made ice cream in my Baking 101 class, the utter feeling of intimidation and dread that I got from learning I had to make it. How in the world could I replicate the delicious creaminess of premium, store bought ice cream? It seems almost impossible! I eventually learned that it’s really as simple as knowing a few key techniques, and practice.
So far in the past four weeks, I’ve made a simple vanilla bean, malted-milk chocolate, buttermilk, and strawberry-nutella. Scouring the various recipe books I have (and the internet), I’ve come to the conclusion that making ice cream is still as fun as it was when I first started.
This week, I’ve decided to make Honey-Vanilla Bean Ice Cream. If you’ve ever had Haagen-Dazs’s Vanilla Honey Bee ice cream, you’ll know exactly what I’m talking about when I start raving about its creaminess, light sweetness, and the overall “melty party in your mouth” sensation. It’s one of my favorite Haagen-Dazs flavors because of its pure, delicious simplicity (plus HD has decided to donate some of its proceeds to fund research to protect disappearing honey bee populations).

I’ve made vanilla bean ice cream recipes that I’ve found in both The Gourmet Cookbook and The New Best Recipe. The former had wonderful flavor – a lot of beautiful vanilla notes accompanied by a slight sweetness from the sugar, but it was lacking a little bit in mouth feel (for my taste anyway). The texture was a little too light for my liking, so I thought I would try the other recipe. The latter, had the opposite effect. It had great texture, but was missing that pop of vanilla that I loved from The Gourmet Cookbook recipe. So I decided to take the best of both worlds, and remove the sugar altogether and replace it with honey.
First off… the honey that I procured, was from the local farmer’s market. It’s really important to get a taste of the variety of honey offered before settling on one to use for ice cream (or anything really). I picked up something called Sage Wildflower honey – the flavors are a little sharper than a typical orange blossom honey, and the color is deeper. I loved it immediately after tasting it, and just had to have it for my ice cream.
I figured, it shouldn’t be too difficult to substitute sugar for honey – after all, the largest concern I really had for the ice cream itself, was the crystallization that sugar often has an effect on its texture. With honey, the trick was to let it dissolve completely (like sugar), when warming up the cream mixture.

Oh heaven. That is all I’m going to say for now.
Honey-Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
2 cups heavy cream
1 cup whole milk
1/2 cup sage wildflower honey
2-3 vanilla beans, split and scraped (depends on your own taste buds! I looooove extra vanilla)
3 large egg yolks
1. Combine cream, milk, vanilla (seeds and pod), honey in a sauce pan. Bring to a boil, stirring occasionally.
2. In a large bowl, lightly whip egg yolks.
3. Temper* the eggs with the hot cream mixture.
4. Return the mixture to the saucepan. On low-medium heat, stir the mixture constantly until slightly thick (you can tell when this is done when it coats the back of the spoon.) Be very careful with this… DO NOT BOIL!!! You want to have a thick, custard like cream, not scrambled eggs.
5. Strain the mixture, and let it chill to room temperature. Refrigerate at least 4 hours so the mixture is completely cool. (at this point you have the vanilla pods still in the mixture. if you’re like me, you hate throwing these things away. so, you’re going to want to rinse them, pat dry, air dry, then add them to a jar of sugar. it’s one of the easiest ways to make homemade vanilla sugar!)
6. Follow the instructions provided with your ice cream machine.
*Temper – to bring the eggs to the same temperature as the hot cream without scrambling them. The trick to doing this is to slowly introduce the hot liquid to the cold eggs. While whisking the eggs constantly in the large bowl, slowly pour about 1/2 cup of hot liquid to the eggs. Do NOT stop whisking – this keeps your egg mixture nice and smooth, and prevents scrambling. Repeat this process until all the hot liquid has been incorporated.